Lighthouse cover
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

Little Lighthouse of Horror Review | Fundamental Flaws

5

Little Lighthouse of Horror is a retro-inspired horror game developed and published by Codiwans. The story revolves around a lone lighthouse keeper struggling with maintaining his position and mysterious occurrences. In doing so he will discover secrets, both wanted and unwanted.

I HEARD YOU LIKE RETRO

Lighthouse visuals
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

The presentation is the first thing that’s going to leave an impression. And it’s the first thing I like to cover in my reviews, so here we are.

As you can see, the game is retro-inspired. You have blocky pixel sprites, limited color schemes, and simplistic animations. To fit the time period and eldritch theme of the game the color palette is muted, comprised entirely of metallic tones. The little background details, such as seagulls flying around or ships sinking because of your incompetence as a lighthouse keeper, as well as the light and weather effects, give the game a layer of depth.

It’s not the most visually distinct pixel presentation, but it is consistent with genuine effort put into it. The soundtrack is mostly atmospheric tracks with a combination of ambient effects. The overall narrative takes a lot of inspiration from popular lighthouse-related media, such as The Lighthouse movie and the mystery of the Flannan Isles. I’d go as far as to say the presentation is the game’s strongest aspect.

MULTITASKING IS THE KEY TO SURVIVAL

Lighthouse gameplay
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

It’s a short, straightforward game. Unfortunately, the list of negatives is longer than the list of positives.

The core gameplay revolves around maintaining your character’s stats. Hunger is recharged by using the stove and having ingredients, sanity by reading, and warmth when standing near a fireplace. You get the idea. There’s a finite amount of supplies you can store and get, so using them cleverly is essential. There’s no overall health system like in DayZ, The Long Dark, Sons Of The Forest, or most other games with a survival mechanic. If a stat reaches zero, it’s game over.  Every week, you can request up to three supply types to be delivered by boat, and depending on your situation, you might have to change your order at the last minute. This is easier said than done and it builds on my main gripe with the game.

The game world isn’t large, and the places you can recover are few, so you’ll quickly memorize the layout. Your first playthroughs are likely going to end in failure as the game doesn’t hold your hand at all. The only tutorial you have is a guide you can consult anytime.

Time flows quickly, and stats drain fast. A single day lasts only a few minutes. The weather is super unpredictable. One moment, it’ll be clear and look like you have time to tend to your needs. Only for a foggy storm to arrive immediately. Have you finished filling the kerosene tank? Well, it’s too bad; you’re almost frozen to death. Do you need wood? It’s too bad the forest is at the other end of the map. You didn’t freeze to death? Too bad you need to fill your stomach. You’re about to fill your stomach? It’s too bad you must bolt and change the lighthouse settings to save precious fuel.

MAD LIKE A LIGHTHOUSE KEEPER

Lighthouse gameplay 2
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

Saying the game world is against you is an understatement. There are a few moments where conquering the challenge is satisfying. But most of the time, playing the game can feel like a chore. Besides constantly worrying about your stats, many things are designed entirely around inconveniencing the player.

Why can’t I carry multiple items at a time? Why is there a gap between the port and the crane when loading supplies? Wouldn’t it make sense to have it right next to the port? So I can quickly load them? Why are there two separate tanks for the lighthouse?

If it sounds like it’ll lead to frustration, it will.

As I said, sometimes conquering that challenge will feel satisfying. Only sometimes. The way the survival mechanics are implemented can make the experience feel super gamey. Calculating exactly how much nutrition you gain, how much sleep recharges, the drain rate of your lighthouse status etc. You’re not immersed in the world, you’re being reminded you’re expected to play in a super specific style. Sadly, frustrations mount, patience dwindles, and some runs can be pointless. There’s an autosave feature that will alleviate the frustration, but it feels like putting on a band-aid when you need intensive surgery. There are multiple endings to tickle your curiosity. However, if the core gameplay is fundamentally flawed, how likely are you to play the game multiple times?

THERE ARE BUGS IN MY LIGHTHOUSE!

Lighthouse bug
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

There are some noticeable bugs.

The first one is regarding item placement. Sometimes, when you have multiple items next to each other or next to an interactable part of the environment, the game will freak out and not let you interact with what you desire. If you open the guide while transitioning between scenes, either by cutscene or while using the stairs in the lighthouse, your character will be stuck. The only way to solve this is by reloading a game, meaning losing progress. By far, the weirdest bug I found is if the autosave feature is enabled and you try to load the game, the dialogue will change to Spanish. This has happened every single time.

CONCLUSION

Lighthouse visuals 2
Screenshot by The Guide Hall

From the surface, it looked like it was something right up my alley. I love retro. I love atmospheric soundtracks. I like Lovecraftian themed stories. But the gameplay is just not satisfying and the rest is just not enough to make me keep going.

Little Lighthouse of Horror Review | Fundamental Flaws
Pros
Charming art style
Cons
Tedious, unsatisfying gameplay
Some glaring bugs
5